Facebook Marketplace or local free groups are always a great place to find toys! I'm a toy collector, myself 😊 I love Squishmallows! I find a lot of mine on Mercari.

You can try here. https://www.secondchancetoys.org/

Or your local Salvation Army and Goodwill. I was shopping at Goodwill recently and you would be pleasantly surprised what you can find there.

Thanks! I've posted on FB groups/Marketplace. No luck so far. I'll check out Mercari:)
Happy hunting on Squishmallows. If I come across someone with them to pass along, I'll remember you! Cheers:)