Connect with others who understand.

  •   Learn from expert-reviewed resources
  •   Real advice from people who’ve been there
  •   People who understand what you’re going through
Sign Up Log In
Powered By
Real members of MyAutismTeam have posted questions and answers that support our community guidelines, and should not be taken as medical advice. Looking for the latest medically reviewed content by doctors and experts? Visit our resource section.
A MyAutismTeam Member asked a question 💭
Panama City, FL

I haved read an article that said that circumcised boys has more chances of developing autism, I feel extremly guilty, please give your thoughts about this issues. Thanks a lot

January 10, 2015
 · 
Be the first to react
A MyAutismTeam Member

Circumcision rates have gone down quite a bit (in the '60's it was around 90% while today it's only around 60%) while the rate of autism has skyrocketed. So it doesn't make sense that there would be a connection.

January 11, 2015
A MyAutismTeam Member

You are going to read articles about many various things that "possibly cause autism" the fact is no one knows the cause yet so rumors fly. Boys have been circumcised for centuries if not longer so I it would be difficult if not impossible to prove this. I would put this rumor or theory on the bottom of potential causes. I used to feel guilty every time another theory came out and now have come to the realization that there was nothing I did or didn't do to cause my sons autism You cant control something that the medical community just doesn't have answers to and may never have.

January 10, 2015
A MyAutismTeam Member

My daughter didn't get autism from a circumcision.

January 14, 2015
A MyAutismTeam Member

There's a new "such and such correlates with autism" study almost every day (no exaggeration). They are virtually all nonsense. This one is especially likely to be nonsense because there's no plausible mechanism for circumcision to result in autism.

One big problem with correlating stuff with autism is that autism is so diverse (it's really many distinct conditions which somehow interfere with social development) and the diverse underlying conditions of autism will correlate with many confounding factors (parental age, ancestral group, socioeconomics, geography, careers, who knows). So you get a lot of correlations that are not causes.

Correlating with autism to find a cause is like correlating with fever or correlating with intellectual disability; there's too much heterogeneity of cause for it to really make sense.

The evidence is pretty clear that the vast majority of autism is genetic; with some "de novo mutation" (genetic changes that were not present in parents) and many cases that are simply a combination of parental genes. The many "correlates with autism" studies can obscure the fact that the evidence for mostly genetics is quite strong. But the genetics are super diverse, like the genetics of intelligence or personality or facial appearance, they aren't a
one-gene-one-disorder kind of thing.

Proposed causes of autism that relate to the genetic mechanisms are much more plausible than those that don't. An example is that as parents age they are more likely to have de novo mutations, so parental age correlates with autism possibly for that reason.

Genetic does not mean immutable or that context and education don't matter. Skills that don't come easily can often be learned, home and school environments can be well-suited to a person or hostile to them, a person with medical conditions unrelated to autism may be uncomfortable or in pain resulting in lots of behavioral and emotional issues, and on and on.

Upbringing and love and opportunity and teaching really matter. That's where parents can make a difference!

January 11, 2015
A MyAutismTeam Member

In our case, we had both antibiotics and Tylenol at the same time very early in life. Antibiotics wipes out the gut flora and Tylenol wipes out glutathione which is the body's primary way to detoxify :( antibiotics use could also be a good confounder not studied here.

There are three researchers that have published on Tylenol hypothesis and ASD risk and now three (not two as mentioned before) correlating Tylenol to adverse neuro development outcomes in offspring in three different countries. It took fewer and weaker correlation studies than this to remove aspirin for paediatric use in the 80s, I believe. Unfortunately Tylenol is prescribed instead of ibuprofen despite studies recommending ibuprofen for pediatric use.

January 15, 2015

Related Questions

View All
A MyAutismTeam Member asked a question 💭
fairfax va, VA

Continue with Facebook
Continue with Google
By joining, you accept our Terms of Use, and acknowledge our collection, sharing, and use of your data in accordance with our Health Data and Privacy policies.
Already a member? Log In