Connect with others who understand.

  • Learn from expert-reviewed resources
  • Real advice from people who’ve been there
  • People who understand what you’re going through
Sign Up Log In
Powered By
Real members of MyAutismTeam have posted questions and answers that support our community guidelines, and should not be taken as medical advice. Looking for the latest medically reviewed content by doctors and experts? Visit our resource section.
A MyAutismTeam Member asked a question 💭
Shreveport, LA

Why is it when your asd child is having a meltdown, the first thing people tell you to do is spank them knowing it's a special needs child?

December 23, 2015
 · 
Reactions

Answer Summary

Members rallied around someone facing judgment from family members who suggested spanking their autistic son during meltdowns, with the... Read more

Members rallied around someone facing judgment from family members who suggested spanking their autistic son during meltdowns, with the overwhelming consensus being that people who don't live with autism daily often fall back on outdated discipline methods without understanding sensory overload or the unique challenges these children face. Several members shared practical alternatives that have worked for their families, including the 1-2-3 Magic timeout system, creating safe spaces like bed tents or cardboard boxes for calming down, using reward systems and token boards, and simply removing the child from overstimulating environments rather than punishing behaviors beyond their control. A recurring theme was the emotional toll of fighting for understanding from unsupportive family members and the relief members found in this community, where they finally felt heard, validated, and less alone in advocating fiercely for their children's needs.

A MyAutismTeam Member

Hi @A MyAutismTeam Member, sorry you had to experience those hurtful words that pull at your heartstrings. WAS it family or strangers?
We experienced both. With family, i am very upfront and honest and say he is having a hard time with. And doesn't know how to express himself, then leave the room to find a quiet place for my son to calm down. We chose not to go to alot of family functions because they didn't want to learn or help us with our son, so sacrificing a party for a happy boy, i still would do anytime.
On the other hand, strangers, i used to ignore their comments. And take a little longer in line helping my son count out money to pay for something he wanted. The ignorance is the hardest thing to accept from the public and even family. But as the years pass you learn u taught someone about autism and maybe it will be spread to others to lesson the ignorance (unknowledgable ).

December 24, 2015
A MyAutismTeam Member

Yes, I agree I was thinking the same thing old school way of thinking?
I wasn't raised being spanked but I do remember my mom slapping my hand (not even hard lol) but it hurt my feelings that bad that I still remember like it was yesterday .
Even people we generally trust like teachers and therapists don't fully understand, because they don't live with autism 24/7 nor are they as emotionally invested to loving our children like parents do.
But as shy as I am, I would be furious if someone suggested spanking my son as a solution.

December 23, 2015
A MyAutismTeam Member

Hello JenniferMendezGerard, your reasons for being is the same reason I am here in this group, they done for more me in the 2 weeks I've joined then those who been around since my son was born, and they also prove to me that they really care, because if it wasn't so, my son would never had the great Christmas he had yesterday from the MAT team when they discovered we had a house fire this month and lost half of our things, this is a great group so welcome to the team.

December 26, 2015
A MyAutismTeam Member

I agree JasonAnderson. We haven't spanked often, and that's our parenting style. That's not the answer. Besides, I have seen the effects of spanking on kids. We know that all the discipline in the world will not guarantee a certain outcome.

December 24, 2015
A MyAutismTeam Member

Yeah. We believe in the reward system. We used a token board for years in the beginning andvit really helped. What i dont like are these "ten years" special ed teachers that refuse to learn something new and that you cant fit a square int a circle, no matter what you do. I'm just grateful, i was able to find a fantastic CBI program for high schoolers that is run by a great district and wonderful people. My son was given so much abuse by his 9th grade teacher, and it was in a county special education system.

January 1, 2016

Related Questions

View All
A MyAutismTeam Member asked a question 💭
Los Angeles, CA, CA

A MyAutismTeam Member asked a question 💭
Jersey City, NJ

Continue with Facebook
Continue with Google
By joining, you accept our Terms of Use, and acknowledge our collection, sharing, and use of your data in accordance with our Health Data and Privacy policies.
Already a member? Log In